Using the safe and effective method for asbestos removal helps avoid potential associated health risks. It may involve two choices: doing it yourself or hiring a professional assistant. Both options have their cons and pros that you must consider to prevent mistakes. A DIY approach to removing asbestos might seem like a way to save money initially, but it carries more risks. Improper handling releases the dangerous fibres that pose not just your but also the health of people living nearby at risk.
By contrast, professional asbestos removal services guarantee a safe, correct and compliant process. It is certain that the method involves an investment. However, it ensures thorough removal and disposal that will protect your health and home.
DIY vs. Professional Asbestos Removal — A Comparison for a Wise Decision
You might need to deal with asbestos when renovating or demolishing an older building or house. A little mistake in handling or disposing of this hazardous substance can contaminate the whole living environment and lead to life-threatening conditions. Therefore, it is important to make an informed decision about whether to remove it yourself or get professional asbestos removal services.
| Factor | DIY Removal | Professional Removal |
| Cost | Seems in budget but includes multiple hidden costs | Higher upfront cost, including all the additional charges |
| Safety | High risk of exposure | Minimised health risks |
| Legality | Restricted in many areas | Fully compliant with laws |
| Effectiveness | Less reliable | Thorough and safe |
| Time Required | Longer due to inexperience | Faster due to expertise and specialized tools |
| Health Risks | Significant | Minimal |
DIY vs. Professional Asbestos Removal – When Can It Be Considered?
Some jurisdictions allow homeowners to remove small amounts of non-friable asbestos (materials that don’t easily crumble) on their own. However, it is important to understand the risks and regulations involved before proceeding.
You can only do DIY removal if:
- ACMs must be in good condition and non-friable. They cannot be easily crumbled or reduced to powder by hand pressure.
- The area to be removed must be small as defined, no larger than 10 sq meters in some regions.
- Regulations often allow homeowners to remove asbestos-containing material in their primary residence.
- You have received proper training on safe removal procedures. You must also be competent, have industry experience, and possess the right equipment for the task.
- Follow safety precautions strictly and have the necessary personal protective equipment.
Licensed asbestos removal professionals follow strict safety protocols to ensure complete and hazard-free management. They also conduct thorough inspections, which you would otherwise need prior to performing the DIY process, to identify the substance’s presence and the extent of severity.
Hire an asbestos removal expert when:
- The substance is in friable form or can be crumbled, pulverized or reduced to powder by hand pressure when dry. It must be removed by a licensed asbestos professional.
- If the area exceeds the locally defined limit.
- Owner-occupants aren’t allowed to perform friable asbestos abatement for demolition projects as they can for renovation projects. You are required to hire an accredited inspector to conduct an asbestos survey for any building constructed prior to 2004. This is to determine the presence of ACMs before demolition.
- If you are unsure about the type of asbestos or the extent of the damage.
- Legal requirements mandate professional removal.
DIY vs. Professional Asbestos Removal — Cost Analysis
When considering asbestos removal, it’s important to compare the costs of both methods to determine your budget and make a good selection.
| Feature | DIY | Professional Service |
| Initial Removal Cost | Seems Lower | Higher – ranging around £950 – £3,750 |
| Safety Gear | Up to £150 | Included in service |
| Survey Cost | £200 to £1000 | Included in the overall service cost |
| Equipment Costs | Requires to spend on respirators, coveralls, eyewear, gloves, HEPA vacuum | Experts are responsible for managing all. |
| Disposal Cost | Environment agency fees and landfill tax apply– vary prices | Included in the overall cost |
| Asbestos Removal Bag | Around £20 | Included |
DIY process may appear cheaper initially, but the cost can escalate than professional removal due to hidden item expenses. These include safety gear, tools and sealants, and disposal fees. Professional service fees incorporate insurance coverage, initial inspection, risk assessment, material removal, and disposal under compliance with regulatory standards. You just need to make one investment, and the company will be responsible for all the extra charges.
Although professional asbestos removal may seem more expensive upfront, it guarantees adherence to safety guidelines and legal requirements, addressing potential issues that DIY methods might not fully cover.
DIY vs. Professional Asbestos Removal — Pros & Cons
Proper risk evaluation is necessary before deciding on any method to deal with ACMs. Weigh the pros and cons of each process, as minor asbestos mishandling can cause serious hazards.
| DIY Removal | Professional Services | |
| Pros | Saving on labour costsAllow to work at your own pace and convenienceOffer a chance to learn more about asbestos and its safe handling | Ensure the job is done safely and professionallyAdhere to all regulations to avoid legal issues.Conduct thorough removal and eliminate asbestos completelyHave specialized equipment to perform the taskPeace of mind for proper waste disposal |
| Cons | Chances of accidental fibre release.Improper handling can cause long-term health issues.May lack the necessary training and experience in asbestos removalUnauthorized DIY asbestos removal may result in fines and legal issuesLack of specialized tools neededIllegal in some states | Can be expensive due to specialized training and equipmentTake time to fulfil all legal requirementsA feeling of lack of control over the method |
Recommendation
Choosing between DIY and professional asbestos removal requires careful consideration, mainly of the risks and legal liabilities. As the substance is critically dangerous, doing removal yourself carries significant health and legal issues and is only allowed under certain conditions. Meanwhile, engaging a professional company provides the expertise and peace of mind needed to ensure the safe and proper removal of ACMs.
The priority should always be protecting the health and well-being of the household. In this case, professional asbestos removal is the more reliable and responsible option.
Davidblogs